Prime Day smackdown: $25 Echo Dot vs. $25 Google Dwelling Mini

Prime Day smackdown: $25 Echo Dot vs. $25 Google Home Mini


$25 buys you one among these. Which one must you select?

Amazon and Google

It is not even Prime Day but (that occurs Monday, as you have undoubtedly heard), however two of the largest rivals in smart-home know-how are already on sale — at costs that match their all-time lows and possibly will not be seen once more till Black Friday. The query: When you’ve acquired some spare money to spend on a sensible speaker, which one must you get?

First, the contenders. Amazon already has a handful of pre-Prime Day offers up and operating, together with the Echo Dot (Third-generation) for $24.99.

In the meantime, Walmart has an entire bunch of Google Dwelling and Nest merchandise on sale, together with the Google Dwelling Mini for $25.

These two hockey pucks usually promote for $50, in order that they’re each 50% off — making this a win-win situation in my e book. That stated, should you do not have already got a sensible speaker (and you are not freaked out by the concept that people is perhaps listening to your queries), is there a transparent winner between these two?

Here is my take: When you personal an Android cellphone, that means you are already acquainted with and accustomed to “OK Google”-ing, the Google Dwelling Mini will suit your life-style higher than an Echo Dot. The previous can also be the better-sounding of the 2, at the very least in response to CNET’s Google Dwelling Mini evaluation.

Nonetheless, the Echo Dot might be the extra versatile of the 2 merchandise, with a bigger choice of abilities and appropriate voice-controlled gadgets. It additionally has extra intuitive contact controls and a line-out jack for connecting exterior audio system. However, it is the extra reserved-looking of the 2, with quite drab black, white and grey shade selections. The Mini, at the very least, has a couple of pastels on the menu. Learn CNET’s Echo Dot evaluation to study extra.

Whichever mannequin you select, you may most likely need to add an exterior speaker. (Each help Bluetooth connectivity.) As a result of whereas they could sound ok to your den or nightstand, let’s be trustworthy: These are small audio system. For large sound, you may want to assist them out. These are our picks for the most effective Bluetooth audio system of 2019.

What do you suppose? If I handed you $25 proper now, which good speaker would you purchase — and why?

Now taking part in:
Watch this:

The right way to resolve on a sensible speaker


CNET’s Cheapskate scours the net for nice offers on PCs, telephones, devices and way more. Notice that CNET could get a share of income from the sale of the merchandise featured on this web page. Questions concerning the Cheapskate weblog? Discover the solutions on our FAQ web page. Discover extra nice buys on the CNET Offers web page and observe the Cheapskate on Fb and Twitter!


CNET could get a fee from retail affords.

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.